Skip to content or navigation


How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture

Architosh is pleased to present this special feature on Bjarke Ingels Group, famed Danish architecture firm. Several weeks ago we got a chance to talk to BIG’s Jakob Andreassen, BIM Manager at BIG Copenhagen, about the architectural practice, its design methodology and perspective on the use of computerized software—particularly BIM.

Continued from page 1

Revit vs ArchiCAD: No ‘Battle Royal’ Here

While the IT press may favor the “battle royal” format for sensationalizing technology’s ongoing progress, when it comes to BIG the scrimmages between combatants are down-played. At BIG the firm has adopted two different BIM software platforms—ArchiCAD and Revit. Yet “adopted” might be too strong a word.

“We are currently not planning on choosing one over the other,” remarked Andreassen.

Andreassen, who is BIM Manager in the Copenhagen office, said he was initially pulled into BIG about one and a half years ago to implement Autodesk Revit. However, the Copenhagen office is currently working with Graphisoft’s ArchiCAD.

“The reason we decided to try out ArchiCAD in Copenhagen is we had a perfect opportunity to try out something new. We had just finished up a lot of work and had the time to try out alternative software.”

Andreassen added that it has been a process getting architects to accept Revit and BIM tools in general. “Since BIM platforms, and Revit in particular, can appear boxy and not very intuitive—it has been hard to get architects using them, as we are insistent on pursuing experimental and innovative architectural ideas.”

03 - BIG's Danish Pavilion at the Expo 2010 in Shanghai, China, exhibits Danish virtues through interaction, allowing visitors to experience the city bike (ultra common in Copenhagen), the harbor bath, and Hans Christiansens' Little Mermaid. (photo by FHKE, distributed under CC-By 2.0)

03 – BIG’s Danish Pavilion at the Expo 2010 in Shanghai, China, exhibits Danish virtues through interaction, allowing visitors to experience the city bike (ultra common in Copenhagen), the harbor bath, and Hans Christian Andersen’s “Little Mermaid.” (image: photo by FHKE, Distributed under CC-By 2.0 License)

“That is the reason we wanted to try ArchiCAD,” he adds. “It doesn’t solve every challenge we as architects face with BIM software but it does seem to have a different appeal among architects. The response among the architects, at least in Copenhagen, is they are actually using it a little earlier in the process.”

BIG’s primary design tool is Rhino, in both Copenhagen and New York City. At the moment the firm is using two different BIM platforms. “Our approach is to always choose the best tool for the job,” he says. “And I can’t say that we wouldn’t choose Revit for a certain project in Copenhagen…and it might also be possible that at some point we run a pilot using ArchiCAD in New York.”

Looking ahead, what is important for BIM at BIG is what Jakob Andreassen refers to as their “BIM Environment,” a flexible arena for data and file formats where information—not proprietary file formats—reign supreme. Not getting “locked in” to one file format is an imperative issue for the firm.

BIG IDEAs—The Role of Technology and Information

One of the more interesting factors at play in BIG’s current and future work is the formation of BIG IDEAS, BIG’s technology-driven special projects division. Led by partner Jakob Lange, and including experts like Tore Banke PhD, BIG IDEAS is responsible for leading the technology management behind the smoke rings at the Amager Bakke energy plant, among other things.

Jakob Andreassen adds, “Tore Banke is an expert at scripting Rhino and Grasshopper and he can do all kinds of customized environmental simulations.” BIG is well aware that its new BIM tools can also add value—to energy calculations in particular—but right now he says “they are kinda going for the low-hanging fruit and getting the designers to bring BIM into the design process.”

“With ArchiCAD we have full-scale models,” he adds, “and we are starting to use the built-in environmental simulations.” For Jakob Andreassen this is one way BIG sees architects starting to gain back control. “We still use external consultants for final details and such, but we use BIG IDEAS for simulations and tests in Grasshopper to get us pretty close to the values that are required by law.

Despite BIG’s abilities and interests in Rhino, scripting, and Grasshopper, Andreassen admits the company doesn’t currently have interest in “in-house” custom software development. The firm does industrial design through BIG IDEAS but it uses its own design staff for that work. With 100 in Copenhagen and over 140 in the New York office, BIG is easily big enough to be a force and influence on software tools development at the software provider level.

Lessons for the Future of Practice

With two Progressive Architecture 2015 honors this year, a global practice which has grown tremendously during the worst years in economic memory, and the ability to fund its own advanced technology and information design division, there are many lessons in BIG from which other architecture firms can draw from.

Insofar as they impact the role of information technologies and their abilities to enable architects to add marked value to society, perhaps the most stunning lesson is the role sheer imagination and invention has played at BIG. As a result, what we hear clearly from BIG’s Andreassen is that software prowess is important but that no one tool—especially a BIM tool—is so important that it rises to the level of the overarching ideas impacting the practice.

Advertisement

Bjarke Ingels’ vision of the architect as midwife squarely puts the architect’s position and responsibility with society on helping mankind adapt in the larger Darwinian sense. This counters the notion of the architect as a stylistic God…and BIG’s work is therefore not always recognizable stylistically. This is also why information has become so important, and partly why, to Andreassen as BIM Manager, the use of BIM in the earlier stages becomes more imperative and critical.

As for the de-Protestant-ization of sustainable design (“it must hurt to do good”) that Ingels suggest architects must embrace, BIG sees each environmental situation as a major ingredient in the narrative way it drums up compelling design visions. Such is the focus of their Washington DC “Hot and Cold: An Odyssey of Architectural Adaption” exhibition. (Edit. note: It runs till 30 August 2015).

Developing BIG IDEAS—its own kind of research and development division—is another lesson to the wider field of architectural practice. The idea of embracing a “lab” or research culture mindset within the practice of architecture fundamentally acknowledges the opportunity architects have to gain back control of the “build process” of architecture. BIM symbolizes many things but one thing it doesn’t yet commonly symbolize is its ability to dissolve the artificial break between the architect and the builder. In our current era, and more so in our near future, architects have the capacity to design direct to manufacture. It is only natural to hear that BIG IDEAS is involved with industrial design—and using its own architectural staff. This is fundamentally no different than learning that Jony Ive, Apple’s famed industrial designer, is heavily involved in the design of Apple’s new corporate headquarters.

At the same time BIG gets it when it comes to the value of information—hence a built-in resistance to file type entrapment. The firm seems to use information to both fuel novelty and narration in its architectural concepts. Both the idea of BIM—as a powerful open and flexible environment—and the notion of empowering the architect to combine his or her design skills with technology and information, contribute to giving the architect back more control to ensure high-level creative work that generates value to society.

 

Footnote: Additional Comments

1—The term phrase “bridge firm” was first heard by the author by architect Pete Evans AIA, senior associate editor at Architosh, who was also on the interview call with Jakob Andreassen. To Evans, it equated simply to a firm that is using BIM but has many “traditional values” about practice. This is a very general and debatable concept, and in the article it was greatly expanded towards a type of specificity that centers a firm between a more Luddite (craft…old ways) culture and a more IT-oriented (automation…new ways) culture.

If we recall the history of the Luddites in the 19th century, the debate in our context boils down to architectural craft versus automation. In the larger architectural sense, BIM’s history put forth its value from a traditional CAD (computer-aided design) perspective, suggesting its efficiencies over 2D CAD. But it also suggested its design benefits in its explicit 3D nature. However, both CAD and BIM, as vehicles of efficiency, can be admonished (by some perspectives) for focusing on the wrong values within architecture.

Creativity, as exemplified by BIG, demonstrates that finding value for architectural clients—especially “discovered” value—or what Bjarke Ingels calls Architectural Alchemy, means that no matter how sophisticated software may become, it is simply no match for the creativity of the human brain and its ability to mix and blend the unexpected. As such, at BIG, as Andreassen said several times in the interview, “software is just a tool.” As such, the BIM Environment at BIG is about being “open” so that blending and mixing are possible. For an architectural alchemist needs his tools to function like a blender that can taken everything.

Pages >

Reader Comments

  1. @architosh important text 🙂

  2. RT @architosh: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture: [Editor’s note: Title graphic image: 8 Ho… http://t.co/z4…

  3. June-Hao Hou liked this on Facebook.

  4. http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  5. http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  6. Hamza Faisal Moshrif liked this on Facebook.

  7. Hamza Faisal Moshrif liked this on Facebook.

  8. @architosh important text 🙂

  9. RT @architosh: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture: [Editor’s note: Title graphic image: 8 Ho… http://t.co/z4…

  10. RT @architosh: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture: [Editor’s note: Title graphic image: 8 Ho… http://t.co/z4…

  11. Unbelievable! I thought the same darn thing when my son was born!

  12. Unbelievable! I thought the same darn thing when my son was born!

  13. Emanuel Machado liked this on Facebook.

  14. June-Hao Hou liked this on Facebook.

  15. Emanuel Machado liked this on Facebook.

  16. June-Hao Hou liked this on Facebook.

  17. Greg Conyngham liked this on Facebook.

  18. Greg Conyngham liked this on Facebook.

  19. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  20. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  21. Ramzi Chahin liked this on Facebook.

  22. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  23. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  24. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  25. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  26. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  27. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  28. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  29. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  30. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  31. Ramzi Chahin liked this on Facebook.

  32. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  33. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  34. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh https://t.co/Zeaw7PzRCZ

  35. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh https://t.co/Zeaw7PzRCZ

  36. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  37. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh http://t.co/MSEfpbSlPa

  38. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  39. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  40. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh http://t.co/MSEfpbSlPa

  41. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  42. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/bvI9zVRG63

  43. Stefan Boeykens liked this on Facebook.

  44. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/bvI9zVRG63

  45. Stefan Boeykens liked this on Facebook.

  46. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  47. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  48. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  49. The concept of architect as mid-wife is quite interesting after one gets over the shock (and fluids…) of it! 😉

  50. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  51. Expertly written article by Architosh on importance of #architect & chosen #technology http://t.co/zpZKnbC0ru https://t.co/O6tcklhU9G

  52. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/7d8Gr6BlpG via @architosh

  53. The concept of architect as mid-wife is quite interesting after one gets over the shock (and fluids…) of it! 😉

  54. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  55. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  56. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  57. Expertly written article by Architosh on importance of #architect & chosen #technology http://t.co/zpZKnbC0ru https://t.co/O6tcklhU9G

  58. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/7d8Gr6BlpG via @architosh

  59. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  60. RT @architosh: http://t.co/VnXupPd1SM — How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh. http://t.co/hMvkkvIV8q

  61. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/OQ6lPSWZTX #BIM #Sustainability #Architecture

  62. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/OQ6lPSWZTX #BIM #Sustainability #Architecture

  63. RT @ArchiCAD: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/OQ6lPSWZTX #BIM #Sustainability #Architecture

  64. RT @ArchiCAD: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture http://t.co/OQ6lPSWZTX #BIM #Sustainability #Architecture

  65. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh https://t.co/9EPOTL90rQ

  66. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh https://t.co/9EPOTL90rQ

  67. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture | Architosh https://t.co/9EPOTL90rQ

  68. Good reading about @BIGstertweets http://t.co/yzsjTRY78U

  69. Good reading about @BIGstertweets http://t.co/yzsjTRY78U

  70. Good reading about @BIGstertweets http://t.co/yzsjTRY78U

  71. Good reading about @BIGstertweets http://t.co/yzsjTRY78U

  72. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6IeV8J

  73. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  74. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  75. RT @randydeutsch: How @BjarkeIngels’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM & the role of the Architect in #Architecture http://t.co/Kx4Pk…

  76. How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6IeV8J

  77. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  78. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  79. […] Architosh, har netop udgivet en artikel omkring brugen af BIM hos BIG – Bjarke Ingels Group. Det er et længere interview med Jakob […]

  80. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  81. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  82. RT @randydeutsch: How @BjarkeIngels’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM & the role of the Architect in #Architecture http://t.co/Kx4Pk…

  83. RT @randydeutsch: How @BjarkeIngels’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM & the role of the Architect in #Architecture http://t.co/Kx4Pk…

  84. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  85. RT @architosh: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture: [Editor’s note: Title graphic image: 8 Ho… http://t.co/z4…

  86. RT @architosh: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture: [Editor’s note: Title graphic image: 8 Ho… http://t.co/z4…

  87. RT @randydeutsch: How @BjarkeIngels’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM & the role of the Architect in #Architecture http://t.co/Kx4Pk…

  88. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  89. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  90. Architect as midwife… this induced our interest http://t.co/UjohYD3OBp #worthreading #BIMready @BIGstertweets @architosh

  91. Architect as midwife… this induced our interest http://t.co/UjohYD3OBp #worthreading #BIMready @BIGstertweets @architosh

  92. […] Wie geht das international bekannte Büro BIG mit BIM (und ARCHICAD) um? […]

  93. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  94. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  95. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  96. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  97. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  98. RT @case_inc: How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of #BIM in #Architecture #BIGarchitecture http://t.co/GU9TjZKv2f http://t.co/jtSG6Ie…

  99. #BIMSummit How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture https://t.co/AtXmmFC9x8 via @architosh

  100. #BIMSummit How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture https://t.co/AtXmmFC9x8 via @architosh

  101. RT @BIMSummit: #BIMSummit How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture https://t.co/AtXmmFC9x8 via @architosh

  102. RT @BIMSummit: #BIMSummit How BIG’s influence can reframe the role of BIM in Architecture https://t.co/AtXmmFC9x8 via @architosh

  103. June-Hao Hou liked this on Facebook.

  104. Ramzi Chahin liked this on Facebook.

  105. Stefan Boeykens liked this on Facebook.

  106. Stefan Boeykens liked this on Facebook.

  107. Ramzi Chahin liked this on Facebook.

  108. Greg Conyngham liked this on Facebook.

  109. Emanuel Machado liked this on Facebook.

  110. June-Hao Hou liked this on Facebook.

  111. Hamza Faisal Moshrif liked this on Facebook.

  112. Emanuel Machado liked this on Facebook.

  113. Greg Conyngham liked this on Facebook.

  114. Hamza Faisal Moshrif liked this on Facebook.

Comments are closed.

 

 

INSIDER Xpresso-4x keeps AEC industry professionals up-to-date on next-gen emerging technologies (emTech) that will revolutionize the worlds of AEC, manufacturing, and design. As an Xpresso-4x reader, you will hear from some of the most important voices inventing and using the very latest tech in areas such as AI, machine learning, algorithm-aided design (AAD), AR/VR/XR, 3D printing, 3D computer vision, robotics, BIM 2.0, Smart Cities technologies and more! 

Each quarterly issue arrives in your Inbox with valuable content you can’t find anywhere else. Issue #1 arrived on March 3, 2019. Issue #53 was our first quarterly issue, arriving in June 2025. Web versions and archives are available and easy to navigate. Enjoy! 

Sign-up for our quarterly newsletter
architosh INSIDER Xpresso.

  • Architosh will never pass any of your information onto third parties.
  • For more information read our privacy policy.
  • It is easy to unsubscribe at any time. Follow the links in the newletter footer.

(Recommended. These infrequent sponsored emails help us to provide our Xpresso newsletter for free.)

 
INSIDER Membership

Read 3 free Feature or Analysis articles per month.

Or, subscribe now for unlimited full access to Architosh.